Botrytis-shrivelled Sémillon grapes hanging in a Sauternes vineyard in autumn, the starting point of any dessert wine guide.
Food Wine

Dessert Wine Guide: Sauternes, Tokaji, Ice Wine and When to Serve Them

Sweet wine is the course most holiday tables skip. This dessert wine guide covers Sauternes, Tokaji, ice wine and their cousins, with the one pairing rule that matters.

Santé may earn a commission when you buy through links in this article.

The one rule in any dessert wine guide is that the wine must be sweeter than the dish. Break it and a good Sauternes tastes thin and sour beside a chocolate tart; keep it and a glass of Tokaji turns a plate of blue cheese into the best course of the night. Everything else follows from that rule. With Thanksgiving a week away and the holiday dinners behind it, this is the moment to understand the three great sweet wines of the world, the cousins worth knowing, and when each belongs on the table.

How sweet wine gets sweet

Every dessert wine is a way of concentrating sugar in the grape faster than the yeast can eat it. There are four methods. Noble rot, the fungus Botrytis cinerea, punctures the skins in humid autumn weather and lets water evaporate, leaving shrivelled berries of honeyed, apricot-scented syrup; this is Sauternes and Tokaji. Freezing does the same job with cold: grapes left on the vine into winter freeze solid, and pressing them while frozen leaves the ice behind and sends only the concentrated juice to the tank; this is ice wine. Drying grapes on mats or in lofts, the passito method, makes Vin Santo and Recioto. And fortification, adding spirit to stop the fermentation with sugar still in the wine, makes Port, Banyuls and sweet sherry, the last covered in our sherry guide. The first three methods leave the alcohol low, usually between seven and fourteen percent, because the yeast gives up before the sugar does.

Sauternes

Sauternes comes from five villages south of Bordeaux where the cold Ciron stream meets the warmer Garonne and throws up morning fog through September and October. Sémillon, with some Sauvignon Blanc and a little Muscadelle, catches the rot unevenly, so pickers pass through the vineyard several times taking only the shrivelled berries. The wine is golden, around fourteen percent alcohol, tasting of apricot, honey, orange peel and, with age, a saffron and marmalade depth that no other sweet wine matches. It is also the most ageworthy white wine in France; the great estates are still fresh at forty. Château d’Yquem sits alone at the top of the 1855 classification, and below it a dozen estates make wine that is close in quality at a fraction of the price. Serve it cold, around 45°F, with Roquefort, with seared foie gras, or on its own after dinner. It is wasted on sweet pastry.

Vineyard rows on a volcanic hillside near the town of Tokaj in northeastern Hungary.
Furmint vines near Tokaj, where autumn mists off the Bodrog and Tisza rivers bring the noble rot that makes Aszú. Photo: Pudelek / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)

Tokaji

Tokaji Aszú from northeastern Hungary was the first great botrytis wine, made in the hills above the town of Tokaj since at least the seventeenth century. The grapes are Furmint, high in acid and prone to rot, with Hárslevelű and a little Muscat. The method is unlike anything in Bordeaux: the shrivelled aszú berries are picked one at a time into baskets, mashed into a paste, and steeped in a base wine or fermenting must, then aged in small casks in cellars cut into volcanic rock. Sweetness was once measured in puttonyos, the baskets of aszú paste added per cask, and the five- and six-puttonyos labels still on the market mark the sweetest styles. The wine is amber, tastes of dried apricot, quince, orange marmalade and smoke, and carries so much acidity that it never feels heavy. The estates rebuilt since 1990, several with Bordeaux money, have made it the most exciting sweet wine region in Europe again. Serve it as you would Sauternes, or with a walnut or poppy-seed cake, and keep a bottle in the cellar: it ages for decades.

Ice wine

Ice wine, Eiswein in Germany and Austria and Icewine as a protected term in Canada, is a race against the weather. Healthy grapes, usually Riesling or the hybrid Vidal, are netted against birds and left on the vine until a hard frost freezes them, at or below 17°F by law in Canada and roughly the same in Germany. Pickers go out at night, often in December or January, and the frozen fruit is pressed at once for a few drops per bunch. The wine is intensely sweet and intensely acidic at the same time, with pure fruit rather than the honey and rot of Sauternes: lime and peach from Riesling, tropical fruit from Vidal. Canada, led by Niagara, is now the largest producer in the world. Ice wine is the dessert wine for actual dessert: it has the sugar to stand up to a fruit tart or a crème brûlée and the acidity to cut through them.

A wind machine standing among netted vines held for ice wine in a Niagara vineyard.
Netted vines left on the wire into winter in Niagara; the grapes are picked frozen, usually at night, at 17°F or colder. Photo: Craig Hatfield / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Three cousins earn a place at the holiday table. Moscato d’Asti, from Piedmont, is lightly sparkling, five and a half percent alcohol and tastes of ripe grapes and orange blossom; it is the one to open at the end of a long lunch when nobody wants more alcohol. Vin Santo, the amber Tuscan wine made from Trebbiano and Malvasia dried on straw mats and aged for years in small sealed casks, is the wine for cantucci and a hard cheese. Pedro Ximénez sherry, black, viscous and tasting of figs and molasses, is fortified, but it is also the only wine that improves vanilla ice cream, which is reason enough to include it.

Dessert wine guide: seven bottles to buy

  • Château Suduiraut Sauternes: a first growth of 1855 next door to Yquem, rich and exotic, and the Sauternes to buy for a cheese course that needs to make a point. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Château Coutet Barsac: from the neighbouring village of Barsac, which may use the Sauternes name but usually does not; lighter, more lemony and the better match for foie gras. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Royal Tokaji 5 Puttonyos Aszú: the Red Label, the most widely available serious Aszú in the United States, with apricot, quince and the volcanic bite that keeps it from cloying. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Disznókő Tokaji Aszú 5 Puttonyos: a single estate on the southern edge of the region, owned by the AXA group that also owns Suduiraut; more delicate than Royal Tokaji, built on acidity. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Inniskillin Vidal Icewine: the Niagara estate that put Canadian Icewine on the map in the 1990s; pineapple, honey and a long, clean finish. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Vietti Cascinetta Moscato d’Asti: the benchmark Moscato from a Barolo house, frothy, fragrant and dry enough at the finish to pour with a fruit tart or a panettone. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Lustau San Emilio Pedro Ximénez: the reference PX from Jerez, for pouring over ice cream or drinking by the thimble with a square of dark chocolate. Shop it at Wine.com

How to serve them

Cold, small and early. All of these wines show best between 43°F and 50°F; a warm Sauternes is a sticky one. Pour two or three ounces into a small white-wine glass, never a cordial glass that hides the aroma, and expect a half-bottle to serve six to eight. Open the Sauternes with the cheese rather than after it, because by the time the dessert plates arrive most of the table has stopped drinking. An opened bottle keeps in the refrigerator for a week or more. If you buy one bottle for the holidays, make it the Royal Tokaji: it costs less than the Sauternes, it outlasts the Moscato, and it is the wine most likely to make a guest who thinks they dislike sweet wine ask for a second glass.

0 comments on “Dessert Wine Guide: Sauternes, Tokaji, Ice Wine and When to Serve Them”

What did you think of this article? We'd love to hear from you!