Oregon Pinot Noir vs Burgundy: What You Get for the Money

Santé may earn a commission when you buy through links in this article.

The honest answer to Oregon Pinot Noir vs Burgundy depends entirely on how much is in your hand. At $25, Oregon wins and it is not close. At $60, the two regions are trading punches, and the better bottle is usually the one from the better producer rather than the better continent. Above $100, Burgundy is selling something the Willamette Valley has not had time to grow: sixty years of vine age, a thousand years of mapped hillsides and a secondary market that treats the wine as an asset. Whether that is worth the premium is a question about you, not the wine.

Both regions grow the same grape in a marginal, cool climate on hillsides that face the morning sun. The differences are soil, history and price, in roughly that order of importance to what ends up in the glass.

Why the comparison exists at all

Oregon invited it. David Lett planted Pinot Noir in the Dundee Hills in 1965 against the advice of his professors at UC Davis, who thought the grape would not ripen there. In 1979 his Eyrie Vineyards 1975 South Block Reserve was entered in a Paris tasting organised by Gault-Millau and finished among the top wines against a field of Burgundies. Robert Drouhin, whose family’s wines had been in that field, organised a rematch in Beaune the following year. Eyrie came second, behind a Drouhin 1959 Chambolle-Musigny, by a fraction of a point.

Drouhin’s response was to buy land. Domaine Drouhin Oregon was established in the Dundee Hills in 1987, and in 2013 Louis Jadot bought the Résonance vineyard in Yamhill-Carlton, its first property outside Burgundy. Other Burgundian families have kept arriving. When Burgundy buys Oregon dirt, Burgundy is telling you what it thinks of the comparison.

Soil, climate and what they do to the wine

The Côte d’Or is limestone and marl, a narrow east-facing escarpment where the best sites sit mid-slope on thin, well-drained soil. The Willamette Valley is volcanic. The red Jory soils of the Dundee Hills are weathered basalt, iron-rich and deep; the sedimentary soils of Yamhill-Carlton and Ribbon Ridge are ancient seabed, faster-draining and lower in nutrients. Jory tends to give rounder, red-fruited, slightly plusher wines; sedimentary sites give darker fruit and firmer tannin. Neither tastes of limestone, because there is none.

Climate is closer than the geography suggests. Both regions sit roughly between the 45th and 47th parallels. Oregon’s winters are wetter and its summers drier; the Pacific sends cool air up the Van Duzer Corridor every evening, which is why Willamette Pinot Noir keeps its acidity even in warm years. Burgundy’s weather is more volatile from vintage to vintage, which is both its risk and the reason vintage charts matter more there.

In the glass, the broad pattern holds: Oregon Pinot Noir is riper, fuller and more generous young, with black cherry and cola notes alongside the red fruit. Burgundy at the same price is lighter in body, higher in acidity, more savoury and more austere at two years old. The gap narrows with better producers on both sides, and it narrows further in warm Burgundy vintages such as 2018, 2019 and 2020, which taste more Oregonian than their fathers did.

Oregon Pinot Noir vs Burgundy at each price

Under $30, Burgundy means Bourgogne Rouge, the regional appellation, where fruit can come from anywhere in the region and the négociant’s blending skill is what you are paying for. The same money in Oregon buys an estate-grown Willamette Valley Pinot Noir from a producer who farmed the grapes. Oregon’s wine is better made, riper and more consistent; the Burgundy is more interesting on the nose and shorter on the palate. For a weeknight, Oregon.

Between $40 and $70 the comparison becomes fair. Burgundy offers village wines from the Côte de Beaune and Côte Chalonnaise, Mercurey, Savigny-lès-Beaune, Chorey-lès-Beaune, from serious domaines. Oregon offers single-vineyard and sub-appellation bottlings from its top names: Dundee Hills, Eola-Amity Hills, Yamhill-Carlton. Oregon’s wines are more immediately satisfying; the Burgundies are more structured and will be better at ten years. At this price, buy whichever you plan to drink first.

Above $100, Burgundy’s premiers crus and grands crus have no real Oregon equivalent, not because the Oregon wines are worse but because nobody has been tasting them for forty years to know how they age. The oldest Willamette vines are younger than the youngest ones in Vosne-Romanée’s grands crus. Oregon’s best wines at this level, from Domaine Serene, Bergström, Beaux Frères and Evening Land, are excellent and comparatively undervalued; they simply have not yet earned the track record that Burgundy charges for.

Seven bottles that make the case

Arranged as three head-to-head pairs and a tiebreaker. All are from producers with wide US distribution.

• Erath Oregon Pinot Noir: The under-$25 benchmark: cherry, soft tannin, correct Willamette acidity, year after year. Shop it at Wine.com
• Louis Jadot Bourgogne Pinot Noir: The Bourgogne Rouge it should be tasted against. Lighter, earthier, more savoury, less fruit. Shop it at Wine.com
• Cristom Mt. Jefferson Cuvee Pinot Noir: Eola-Amity Hills, whole-cluster fermentation, a stemmy, spicy wine that could pass for the Côte de Nuits blind. Shop it at Wine.com
• Domaine Faiveley Mercurey: A Côte Chalonnaise village wine from a major domaine; firm, red-fruited and a fair fight for the Cristom at similar money. Shop it at Wine.com
• Domaine Drouhin Oregon Dundee Hills Pinot Noir: The Drouhin family’s answer to its own question. Jory soil, Burgundian winemaking, Oregon fruit. Shop it at Wine.com
• Joseph Drouhin Cote de Nuits-Villages: Same family, same philosophy, limestone instead of basalt. Taste the two side by side. Shop it at Wine.com
• Willamette Valley Vineyards Whole Cluster Pinot Noir: The tiebreaker for the budget: bright, carbonic-style fruit, built to drink this year, and the better bottle at its price on either continent. Shop it at Wine.com

The verdict, and when to pay the premium

Buy Oregon for the next five years of drinking and Burgundy for the five after that. Oregon’s weakness is not quality but predictability of style; the region has yet to settle whether it wants to be the Côte de Nuits or the Russian River, and its sub-appellations are still proving themselves. Burgundy’s weakness is price, and it gets worse every vintage.

Pay the Burgundy premium when the producer’s name is the reason you are buying, when you intend to cellar the wine for a decade, or when the occasion calls for the original. For every other evening, including Thanksgiving on the 26th, where a riper, friendlier Pinot Noir suits the table better anyway, the Willamette Valley is the smarter cheque. Cellar advice for either is in our winter guide to stocking a cellar, and the grape’s Burgundian home is covered in Wine A to Z by Santé.