A roast turkey ready for carving, the starting point for any turkey wine pairing.
Food Wine

Turkey Wine Pairing: Why Pinot Noir Isn’t the Only Answer

The turkey is not the problem; the gravy, the brine and the smoke are. Eight bottles that beat Pinot Noir with the bird, matched to how you cook it.

Santé may earn a commission when you buy through links in this article.

Pinot Noir became the default turkey wine pairing because it is red, light enough not to bully white meat and expensive enough to feel like an occasion. It works. It is also the least interesting answer to the question, because the turkey itself is the least demanding thing on the plate. Roast turkey breast is mild, lean and slightly sweet; it will go with almost anything that is not heavily tannic or heavily oaked. What decides the pairing is everything the bird arrives with: the gravy, the brine, the smoke if it was smoked, the oil if it was fried, and the sweet, sour and bitter sides crowding the plate around it.

So the useful way to choose is to start with how the turkey was cooked and what is being ladled over it, then pick a wine with the acidity, fruit and weight to cope. Pinot Noir is one of several right answers, and below are eight others, each matched to a method. Our Pairing column covers the sides elsewhere; this is about the bird.

What a turkey wine pairing actually needs

Three things. Acidity first, because gravy is fat and flour and the plate is rich; a wine without enough acid tastes flat by the second bite. Fruit second, and preferably ripe fruit, because turkey is faintly sweet and so is nearly every side dish, from the glazed squash to the cranberry; a bone-dry, austere wine fights the sweetness and loses. Restraint on tannin and oak third, because breast meat has almost no fat to soften tannin, and heavy oak flattens the bird’s delicate flavour into vanilla.

Those three rules explain why Pinot Noir works and point directly to its rivals: Gamay, dry and off-dry Riesling, Chenin Blanc, Grenache-based blends, well-made Zinfandel and dry sparkling wine. They also rule out the two wines people most often bring: young Cabernet Sauvignon, which is all tannin and no acid against white meat, and buttery Chardonnay, which doubles the richness of the gravy.

Plain roast turkey: Gamay and Chenin Blanc

A simply roasted, unbrined bird with pan gravy is the easiest case, and the best turkey wine pairing for it is cru Beaujolais. Gamay from Morgon, Fleurie or Moulin-à-Vent has Pinot’s weight and red fruit with more acidity and a lower price, and it is better at the table than anything with the word Nouveau on it, as we argued last month. Serve it slightly cool. For a white, Loire Chenin Blanc with a touch of residual sugar is the one wine that improves every single thing on a Thanksgiving plate.

  • Louis Jadot Chateau des Jacques Moulin-a-Vent: Serious Beaujolais with the structure of a Côte de Beaune village wine, floral, dark cherry, firm acid. Open an hour ahead. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Georges Duboeuf Fleurie: The lighter, prettier cru: violets, raspberry, soft texture. The bottle to put in front of guests who insist they only drink Pinot. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Champalou Vouvray: Demi-sec in style, honeyed pear and quince over bright acidity. Handles turkey, gravy, cranberry and sweet potato without flinching. Shop it at Wine.com
Vineyards in Beaujolais wine country.
Beaujolais: the cru villages give Gamay the structure a Thanksgiving table needs. Photo: Geoff Wong / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Brined or herb-butter turkey: Riesling

Brining adds salt deep into the meat and makes it juicier and more savoury, and salt is Riesling’s best friend. A Kabinett from the Mosel, with its low alcohol, pronounced acidity and faint sweetness, handles a brined bird the way it handles pork and sauerkraut: the salt makes the wine taste drier, the sugar makes the meat taste richer, and the acid cleans the plate. If the bird has been rubbed with herb butter or roasted under bacon, step up to a dry Alsace Riesling with more body.

  • Dr. Loosen Dr. L Riesling: Mosel Kabinett-level sweetness, green apple and slate, under 9% alcohol. Chill hard; the best-value bottle on this list. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Trimbach Riesling: Alsace, bone dry, lime and stone, with the weight to stand up to butter and bacon. Decant it; young Trimbach is tight. Shop it at Wine.com

Smoked or fried turkey: Zinfandel and Grenache

Smoking changes everything. Smoked turkey is darker, sweeter and tastes of wood and char, and a delicate Pinot Noir disappears against it. The wine needs ripe fruit, moderate tannin and a bit of spice of its own: Zinfandel from Sonoma or the Sierra Foothills, or a Grenache-led Côtes du Rhône. Deep-fried turkey, with its crisp skin and juicy, slightly richer meat, sits between the two methods and takes either style, though a lighter hand on the oak is wise.

  • Seghesio Sonoma Zinfandel: Brambly fruit, black pepper, enough acidity to keep it lively. Made for smoke. Shop it at Wine.com
  • E. Guigal Cotes du Rhone: Grenache, Syrah and Mourvèdre; garrigue, plum and a savoury edge that meets charred skin halfway. A dependable magnum for a crowd. Shop it at Wine.com
A Thanksgiving dinner table laid with the full spread of dishes.
The turkey is the easy part; the sides are what the wine has to survive. Photo: Helena Jacoba / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0)

Dark meat, and the case for bubbles

If your table divides into breast people and thigh people, the thigh people can have more wine. Dark meat has fat and a deeper, almost gamey flavour that can handle moderate tannin, which is the moment for the Moulin-à-Vent or the Côtes du Rhône rather than the Fleurie. The breast people are better served by the Vouvray and the Riesling. Open one of each and let the plate decide.

The one wine that serves both camps, every cooking method and the full run of sides is dry sparkling wine, and it remains the most underused turkey wine pairing in the country. Acidity and carbonation scrub the palate of gravy; the bread and apple notes of a traditional-method sparkler echo the stuffing; and it does not care whether the bird was brined, smoked or fried.

  • Roederer Estate Brut: Anderson Valley, traditional method, Chardonnay and Pinot Noir. Dry, toasty, under the price of most Champagne and better than much of it at the table. Shop it at Wine.com

Buy two bottles of whichever matches your method and one of the Roederer for the first glass, and leave the Pinot Noir to whoever is bringing it anyway. For the bottles the rest of the meal needs, from the oysters to the pie, our oyster guide and the twelve-bottle Thanksgiving plan published last month have the table covered.

0 comments on “Turkey Wine Pairing: Why Pinot Noir Isn’t the Only Answer”

What did you think of this article? We'd love to hear from you!