Santé may earn a commission when you buy through links in this article.
The short answer to what is a Super Tuscan: a red wine from Tuscany that was made outside the region’s appellation rules, usually because it contained Cabernet Sauvignon or Merlot, or because it was Sangiovese without the white grapes Chianti once required, or both. For twenty years these wines could only be labelled Vino da Tavola, table wine, the lowest category in Italian law, while selling for more than any Chianti. The name was coined by the English-language press in the 1980s, has never had a legal definition, and today covers everything from a $20 Toscana IGT blend to Sassicaia. That range is the reason the term needs explaining before anyone buys on the strength of it.
Where the rules came from, and why they were broken
The Chianti rulebook, codified in the 1960s from Baron Ricasoli’s nineteenth-century formula, required a blend of Sangiovese with Canaiolo and a share of white grapes, Trebbiano and Malvasia, which lightened the wine and were there to make a fast-drinking product. By the 1970s the better estates found the rule absurd: it banned the thing they wanted to make, a serious, long-lived red, and compelled the thing they did not, a thin one.
Two estates broke it from different directions. On the coast at Bolgheri, Mario Incisa della Rocchetta had planted Cabernet Sauvignon at Tenuta San Guido in 1944, for family consumption, on land that had no DOC at all. Sassicaia’s first commercial vintage was 1968, released in 1971, and it arrived tasting like a Bordeaux with Tuscan sun in it. Inland, in Chianti Classico, Piero Antinori released Tignanello from the 1971 vintage as a Vino da Tavola, aged in small French barrels; within a few vintages he had dropped the white grapes altogether and added Cabernet, accepting the humble label as the price of making the wine he wanted.
The market did the rest. By the early 1980s Solaia, Ornellaia and a wave of imitators were selling at prices the DOC wines could not reach, and the word Super Tuscan was being used, half in admiration and half as a joke, for table wines with first-growth price tags.

How the law caught up
Italy’s 1992 wine law, the Goria law, created the IGT category, Indicazione Geografica Tipica, which allowed a regional name on the label with far looser rules on grapes and methods. Toscana IGT became the natural home for the Super Tuscans, and most still carry it. Bolgheri got its own DOC for red wine in 1994, with a sub-zone, Bolgheri Sassicaia, for a single estate; it became a DOC in its own right in 2013, the only single-estate appellation in Italy. Chianti Classico rewrote its rules in 1996 to permit 100% Sangiovese and later banned white grapes outright, which quietly removed the original reason for rebellion.
The result is that a wine can be a Super Tuscan in spirit and a Bolgheri DOC, a Toscana IGT or even a Chianti Classico on the label. The term is a description of a style and a history, not a category you can look for on the bottle.
What is a Super Tuscan today, in the glass
There are two families, and they taste different. The coastal wines, from Bolgheri and the Maremma, are Bordeaux-style blends built on Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Merlot, sometimes with Syrah or Petit Verdot and sometimes with no Sangiovese at all. They are full, dark-fruited, cedar-scented and polished, and the best of them age for thirty years. The inland wines, from Chianti Classico and Montalcino, are Sangiovese-led, often 100% Sangiovese, with the grape’s sour cherry, dried herbs, firm acidity and dusty tannin, aged in French oak that the traditional Chianti producers avoided. Some add a share of Cabernet or Merlot to fill out the middle.
The label will not tell you which family a bottle belongs to. The grape blend sometimes appears on the back; the place name is the better clue. Bolgheri means Bordeaux varieties. A Chianti Classico estate’s IGT bottling almost always means Sangiovese. A Toscana IGT with a fantasy name and no estate behind it is usually a Merlot-Sangiovese blend made for export, pleasant and forgettable.
Eight bottles worth the name
Prices run from a weeknight red to a wine that needs a decade in a cellar. All have wide US distribution. Vintage advice for the Sangiovese-based ones follows the same windows as Brunello, which we covered in our Brunello vintage guide.
- Tenuta San Guido Sassicaia: The original and still the reference: Cabernet Sauvignon and Cabernet Franc, Médoc structure, Mediterranean fruit. Buy to hold. Shop it at Wine.com
- Tenuta San Guido Guidalberto: The estate’s second label, with Merlot in the blend; drinkable at five years and the affordable way into the house style. Shop it at Wine.com
- Antinori Tignanello: Sangiovese with Cabernet, the wine that proved Chianti Classico could make a great red outside the rules. Decant two hours. Shop it at Wine.com
- Le Serre Nuove dell’Ornellaia: Ornellaia’s second wine, Merlot-led, plush and ready young. The best-value Bolgheri from a top estate. Shop it at Wine.com
- Guado al Tasso Il Bruciato: Antinori’s Bolgheri entry point: Cabernet, Merlot and Syrah, and a reliable introduction to the coastal style. Shop it at Wine.com
- Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve: Pure Sangiovese from Panzano, aged in French oak; the inland Super Tuscan at its most serious. Shop it at Wine.com
- Isole e Olena Cepparello: Another 100% Sangiovese, more perfumed and finer-boned than Flaccianello. A benchmark for the grape. Shop it at Wine.com
- Luce della Vite Lucente: Sangiovese and Merlot from Montalcino, the second wine of Luce; supple, modern and built for the dinner table rather than the cellar. Shop it at Wine.com

How to buy without overpaying for the word
The name carries a premium, and plenty of producers have noticed. A good test is to ask what the wine would be called if the Super Tuscan label did not exist. If the answer is Bolgheri DOC from a known estate, or an IGT Sangiovese from a Chianti Classico house with a serious reputation, the premium is earned. If the answer is a Toscana IGT with a made-up name, a heavy bottle and no estate address, the wine is trading on history that belongs to someone else, and a well-made Chianti Classico Riserva at the same price will be better.
Serve the coastal wines as you would Bordeaux, at cellar temperature with a long decant and red meat. Serve the Sangiovese wines as you would a good Chianti, slightly cooler, with anything involving tomatoes, rosemary or a wood fire. The truffle season now under way suits both; our truffle pairing guide explains why. And if the question is which single bottle to open this month, it is Guidalberto: the whole story of the category, at a price that leaves room for a second bottle.

0 comments on “What Is a Super Tuscan? The Bottles That Broke the Rules”