A mug of mulled wine at a German Christmas market, the model for any mulled wine recipe.
Food Spirits

Mulled Wine Done Properly: The Bottle, the Spices, the Method

Never boil it, never use a wine you would not drink, never drown it in sugar. The bottle, the spices and the method for mulled wine that tastes of wine.

Santé may earn a commission when you buy through links in this article.

A proper mulled wine recipe has three rules, and most of the ones in circulation break all of them. Never boil it. Never use a wine you would not drink from the glass. Never load it with sugar and then wonder why it tastes like cough syrup. Get those right and mulled wine is a serious drink, closer to a warm, spiced Rhône than to the thin, sweet stuff ladled out at holiday markets, and it costs about the same as a bottle of decent red and a trip to the spice drawer.

The version below is built for a 750 ml bottle and serves six in small cups, which is the right size; mulled wine is for one or two cups by the fire, not a session. Double it in a larger pot without doubling the spices.

The bottle: fruit, low tannin, no oak

Heat flattens aroma and sharpens tannin, so the wine that works best is fruity, medium-bodied and soft. A big, oaky Cabernet turns bitter in the pot; a thin, acidic red turns sour. The sweet spot is Grenache, Merlot, Zinfandel, Primitivo or a Southern Rhône blend, between 13 and 14.5 percent alcohol, under $20, with ripe fruit and little or no new oak. The spice and citrus will dominate, but a wine with real fruit underneath is the difference between mulled wine and hot spiced sugar water.

  • E. Guigal Côtes du Rhône Rouge: Syrah, Grenache and Mourvèdre with dark berry fruit and a peppery edge that matches the spices; the benchmark bottle for this. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Bodegas Borsao Tres Picos Garnacha: old-vine Garnacha from Campo de Borja, plush and ripe, which carries orange and cinnamon without needing extra sugar. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Seghesio Sonoma Zinfandel: brambly, spicy Zinfandel that takes to clove and star anise as if it were made for them; the best of the three if the budget allows it. Shop it at Wine.com

Cheap jammy reds from the supermarket work in a pinch, but the sweet ones already carry residual sugar, so cut the added sugar below by half. Skip anything labeled “smooth” or “velvety” in a glossy bottle; those are the wines with the most sugar and the least fruit.

The spices, whole and few

Ground spices turn mulled wine cloudy and gritty; whole spices give clean flavor and strain out. For one bottle, this is enough:

  • 2 cinnamon sticks (Ceylon if you can find it; cassia is harsher)
  • 6 whole cloves
  • 2 whole star anise
  • 4 green cardamom pods, lightly crushed
  • 1 strip of orange peel, pith removed, plus the juice of half the orange
  • 4 thin slices of fresh ginger
  • 3 tablespoons of sugar, honey or maple syrup, to start
  • 1 split vanilla pod (optional, and worth it)

Nutmeg and allspice are traditional but easy to overdo; a single grating of nutmeg at the end is plenty, and allspice is better left out. Bay leaf, black peppercorns and a dried fig or two are legitimate additions. Dried fruit of any kind adds sweetness, so reduce the sugar if you use it.

Star anise and cinnamon sticks, the two spices that carry mulled wine.
Star anise and cinnamon: whole spices only, never ground. Photo: Retro Lenses / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

The method: infuse, then warm

The mistake in almost every mulled wine recipe is to put everything in a pot and simmer it for an hour. Alcohol begins to evaporate at 173°F (78°C), the fruit aromas go with it, and the tannins concentrate as the liquid reduces. The fix is to build the spice base in a small amount of liquid first and add the wine only at the end.

  • Put the sugar, spices, orange peel, orange juice and ginger in a saucepan with about 1/2 cup (120 ml) of the wine. Bring to a simmer, stir until the sugar dissolves, and let it bubble gently for 4 to 5 minutes until syrupy and fragrant. This is the only moment anything should boil.
  • Turn the heat to low and add the rest of the bottle. Warm, uncovered, to about 150°F (65°C), which is hot to the touch but well below steaming; a thermometer helps the first time. Hold there for 15 to 20 minutes.
  • Taste. Add sugar a teaspoon at a time if it needs it, or a squeeze of lemon if it has gone flabby. The target is a drink that is warm, aromatic and only just sweet.
  • Strain through a fine sieve into a warm jug or straight into cups. Serve in small heatproof glasses or mugs, not full wine glasses; four to five ounces is a serving.

Mulled wine holds on the lowest burner setting, lid on, for an hour or so. Beyond that the spices turn medicinal; strain them out and reheat gently as needed. A slow cooker on “warm” works for a party, again with the spices removed after the first half hour.

The fortification that makes it a drink

The addition that separates a good mulled wine from a great one is a measure of something stronger, added off the heat so it does not cook away. This is where the spirits cabinet earns its keep.

  • Brandy or Cognac: 2 to 3 ounces per bottle, stirred in at the end. A VS such as Hennessy or Rémy Martin is right; save the VSOP for the glass.
  • Ruby or tawny port: 3 to 4 ounces per bottle adds body and a dried-fruit sweetness that lets you cut the sugar entirely. A 10-year tawny is the luxury version. Taylor Fladgate 10 Year Tawny Port is the one to buy for both the pot and the glass. Shop it at Wine.com
  • Grand Marnier or Cointreau: 1 to 2 ounces for orange depth; this is the Swedish glögg instinct, where the pot usually gets aquavit or vodka and a handful of raisins and almonds.
  • Dark rum or Calvados: 2 ounces of either moves the drink toward a hot toddy; apple brandy in particular suits a Zinfandel base.
Mulled wine warming in a pot with citrus and spices.
Warm, never boil: the pot should steam, not bubble. Photo: Angela Huster / Wikimedia Commons (CC0)

What to serve with it

Mulled wine is sweet and spiced, so it wants food that is salty, nutty or sharp. Aged Gouda, Manchego and Comté; toasted almonds with rosemary and salt; Lebkuchen or gingerbread; a slab of Stollen; or, best of all, a plain mince pie, which was invented for exactly this. It fights with chocolate and with anything creamy.

White mulled wine is worth making once, with a dry Riesling or Pinot Gris, lemon peel in place of orange, and a thumb of ginger, cardamom and a single cinnamon stick; add an ounce of elderflower liqueur at the end. For the Thanksgiving weekend, make the red the night before, strain it, refrigerate it, and reheat gently as guests arrive. The spices settle overnight and the second day is always better than the first.

0 comments on “Mulled Wine Done Properly: The Bottle, the Spices, the Method”

What did you think of this article? We'd love to hear from you!